Copilot to pilot | Rohith Pudari

This text was created from my defense presentation of my Master’s thesis, given at the University of Victoria, 23 August 2022. The thesis titled “AI Supported Software Development: Moving Beyond Code Completion” is available here.

References

2023

From Copilot to Pilot: Towards AI Supported Software Development

Rohith Pudari, and Neil A. Ernst

2023

Abs arXiv Bib Slides

AI-supported programming has arrived, as shown by the introduction and successes of large language models for code, such as Copilot/Codex (Github/OpenAI) and AlphaCode (DeepMind). Above human average performance on programming challenges is now possible. However, software engineering is much more than solving programming contests. Moving beyond code completion to AI-supported software engineering will require an AI system that can, among other things, understand how to avoid code smells, to follow language idioms, and eventually (maybe!) propose rational software designs. In this study, we explore the current limitations of AI-supported code completion tools like Copilot and offer a simple taxonomy for understanding the classification of AI-supported code completion tools in this space. We first perform an exploratory study on Copilot’s code suggestions for language idioms and code smells. Copilot does not follow language idioms and avoid code smells in most of our test scenarios. We then conduct additional investigation to determine the current boundaries of AI-supported code completion tools like Copilot by introducing a taxonomy of software abstraction hierarchies where ’basic programming functionality’ such as code compilation and syntax checking is at the least abstract level, software architecture analysis and design are at the most abstract level. We conclude by providing a discussion on challenges for future development of AI-supported code completion tools to reach the design level of abstraction in our taxonomy.
@misc{pudari2023copilot, title = {From Copilot to Pilot: Towards AI Supported Software Development}, author = {Pudari, Rohith and Ernst, Neil A.}, year = {2023}, eprint = {2303.04142}, archiveprefix = {arXiv}, primaryclass = {cs.SE}, doi = {10.48550/arxiv.2303.04142}, }

Enjoy Reading This Article?

Here are some more articles you might like to read next: